Hugh Smith
This story was a rambling, frankly boring predictable journey. Nothing happens that is note worthy. It was a vehicle to allow the author the indulgence of fulfilling their desire to have two historical figures separated by time clash.... Predictably no answers or real conclusions, the final act is rushed and lacking the dull details that the previous sections of the book were full of. The final section is just a rushed setup for the next book.
1 person found this review helpful
Antonio Salazar
This first book is basically a historical fiction novel with splashes of science fiction, feels more like an experiment. You could skip it and not hurt your understanding of the second and third books. You will find several pop culture Sci-Fi references forced into the plot, which along occasional (but crucial to the plot) scientific impossibilities, make this a below-average work for something carrying the Clarke surname. Speaking about the rest of the series, at the end of the third book it remains unfinished. Unfortunately, Sir Clarke died in 2008, and it's uncertain if the series is truncated or on hold. Given its quality, it could certainly go on without him.