Dali Castillo
Her Amish Suitor's Secret is a wonderful blend of mystery (which kept me guessing to the very end), faith, and romance. For Caleb, devotion to family made him take on a false identity. For Rose, a past hurt fueled her independent spirit. However, even with such differences, Rose and Caleb form a friendship that is endearing and yet at times painful. The combination of how their relationship plays out, along with the mystery aspect and the faith message made this an absolute must read.
Kristina Anderson
Her Amish Suitor’s Secret by Carrie Lighte has Caleb Miller, an Englischer, taking a job as groundskeeper for the summer at an Amish lakeside camp in Serenity Ridge, Maine. His brother, Ryan has been accused of stealing rare coins from the museum where he worked as an archivist. A flyer sent in the mail to Ryan anonymously pointed them towards the camp. The FBI had not been able to find any evidence, but the camp is surrounded by acres of woodland. Rose Allgyer is running the camp for the summer and, after a recent incident with her former fiancé, she is leery of men. As time passes, Rose and Caleb get to know each other and develop feelings. But Caleb’s deceit stands in their way. Her Amish Suitor’s Secret is the third novel in Amish of Serenity Ridge. It can be read on its own for those new to the series (like me). I thought Her Amish Suitor’s Secret was well-written with interesting characters. I liked Rose and Caleb. It was fun watching them get to know each other after a bumpy beginning. There is humor sprinkled throughout out the book. The mystery of the coin was more of a side story than the primary focus. I like how the book ended. I now want to read the other two novels in Amish of Serenity Ridge series. Her Amish Suitor’s Secret is a sweet, relaxing tale which is the type of book you want at the end of the long, stressful day.