Julie Thewlis
This book is very good, well written, has humour but also sadness, kept me reading and interested (even though I'd already seen the film). The reason that I'm glad I watched the film first is that I feel the characters were played much more sympathetically in the film than they were written in the book. Alexander in particular sometimes came across as mean spirited towards Stuart in the book and this left a bad taste, I am glad some of his private thoughts towards Stuart were left out of the film.
1 person found this review helpful
Sarah Smith
I love this book. Just finished it and as much as it's left me feeling desperately sad for Stuart, it has made me much more aware of how homelessness and mental health are dealt with by 'the system'. A powerful insight in to how people end up the way they do, and how childhood events can make or break a personality. Brilliant character development and story-telling - kudos to Stuart for suggesting the book be written 'backwards', and a murder mystery. Want to see the film now!
2 people found this review helpful
A Google user
One of the most searing portraits of social exclusion I've come across, but not a bleeding heart excuse fest at the same time. Stuart is portrayed as human and comprehensible, and dignified in choosing his own way. The fact that that was not the way society approved of is by the bye; this is a really good book.