The Prophet of Yonwood

You’d have to keep in mind, this is a prequel. So none of the characters in previous books will be featured in the book. It took me a bit to get used to this, but the main storyline was interesting. I liked Nickie, but there were times when I didn’t. Although it wasn’t entirely her fault (due to the brainwashing), you’d think at her age (11) she might be able to tell what’s right or wrong. So I thought she acted way younger than she is, and was just a little too naive. There were also times where I couldn’t help but feel angry. I couldn’t stand Brenda. I wanted to choke her out of the book. It’s these kinds of people that blow everything out of proportion and made the situation more dangerous and harmful than it really is. When the incident with the dogs happened this was where I just about had it with her and wanted a bomb to drop on her house. Despite my intense dislike for this character, I liked how the book shows the reader how this sort of situation can show the worst (and the best) characteristics in individuals. I bothers me a little, that this really has nothing to do with Ember (until you find out much later, near the end of the book) and it may annoy readers as it’s oddly placed in the middle of the series, and some might argue that it’s not a prequel at all. The plot was good, although it was slow moving. You’re more than halfway through the book and the plot is still crawling. My suggestion, is to skip this book and read the fourth one, then read this one. You won’t be missing much anyway. It’s not the best I’ve read from the author but it’s readable if one wants to complete the series.

Honestly this was extremely disappointing. In fact it was quite a struggle for me to slog through it due to the lack of anything happening. This shouldn't qualify as a prequel. If you want the "prequel" to the city of ember, just read the last chapter. The rest of the book isn't worth the time.

This book should have been made after the fourth book of Ember as like a prequel to fill in the unanswered questions. Instead they made this book right in the middle of the serise. The writing isn't much better, just a story of a girl and to many plot points to count.