Malie
Only about half the book seems relevant--it's very slow until a speedy last quarter. The author is long-winded in her descriptions and I found myself listening at 1.25x to move it along. The narrators are decent; it's the writing that's laborious. The ending is unpredictable because it's almost a completely different story from the one you've endured for hours. I appreciate the tidy ending, however it lacks dialogue or insight from the most central characters, namely Leo. Given the whole book is a series of monologue POV's, I don't quite understand that choice. If you're in for a lazy read, this book might be ok, otherwise I can't recommend it.
Brandi
It started off very intense and engaging. Some highs and lows in the middle and the ending felt very rushed. I really loved all of Leo's and Meredith's sections. Kate's section was at times not very interesting and felt it wasn't need. However, I see why it was. I would have loved a POV chapter on how Josh dealt during those missing 11 years. It was a good book that kept me guessing and invested in what happened.
Laura W
It was a good mystery told in a different sort of way and that was enjoyable. There were some things the characters did, I'm guessing to fit into the plot line, that seemed dumb and that took away a little from the story. Overall, I would recommend.